posted by Trash on 2004-05-09 21:20:38 | | First off - how original is an evil magic item that turns a non-evil PC into evil without a saving throw... can we say monty hall-ism?!? Second is the fact that this so called artifact only turns someone into evil "in a few days" - whatever that means - a few days could be a week or longer to some people's definitions. Please no more lame submissions!! |
posted by Vern on 2004-05-09 21:46:55 | | LOL @ No Saving Throw!! I guess a DM would really have to hate a player to not allow a saving throw |
posted by Tarun the Slick on 2004-05-13 09:20:50 | | Average, vanilla...but useable to a DM in a pinch. You should list this under 2nd Edition for those whom still play that version. Waste of time for 3d. |
posted by Erebus on 2004-05-15 08:29:02 | | No I think this is simple enough to appeal to 3ED players. Which is my criticism - the situation is very simplistic without any real innovation. However it was written up in a very articulate and accessible way - top marks on that front. It is certainly 'ready to use'. I would certainly be interested in something from the same contributor with a few more plot twists. |
posted by Cerwin Vega on 2004-05-16 12:00:24 | | Hey Darren, Get the hint that submitting a 2nd Ed. D&D game DOES NOT belong in the D20 section. How lame can you be to insult us D20 players by saying it can be converted, why not do the conversion yourself before submitting so that we don't have to waste our time with your crap, list it right next time idiot! |
posted by Vinz on 2004-05-23 14:34:17 | | I think you d20 guys made your point, no need to get so rude. |
posted by Darren White on 2004-05-25 10:05:05 | | No that was not me, a am against pumping up your own material with fake comments (although they really don't mean much anyway). To all the d20 users that I have offended...I apologize and will now list my work under 2nd Edition or convert them over as I now have the newer editions. |
posted by ElfAssassin on 2004-06-01 13:44:34 | | Well written and easily adaptable to any campaign. A lot of people are complaining about no saving throw. If you want your Players to be allowed a saving throw, give them one. As far as this being under the d20 section, I found it listed under D&D Forgotten Realms, not d20 Dungeons and Dragons. Are the d20 players trying to claim the world specific sections as their own? If so, get a clue. The only section specifically designated for you is, D20 Dungeons and Dragons. Now, quit wasting valuable comment space and go Roll play, because I doubt of any you are Role players. |
posted by Better Than Some, But.... on 2004-06-07 19:03:49 | | Better thyan some, but not my style... as far as ElfAssassin, well all i got to say is everybody is entitled to their opinions no matter if you agree or not. It's too bad that some people who can't take an honest comment about a submission without being insulting to fellow gamers have to do battle within the confines of a comment board. I think the person who runs this site needs to dump the comments part of this site.... |
posted by Kandie on 2004-06-24 07:42:54 | | I would have given it a better rate, but due to the lack of maps (which is obviously something that is a problem with all your adventures) I would never use your stuff. If you don't have any money to buy a decent map program, go to www.dungeoncrafter.com and d/l that one, it is a freebie and would enhance your stuff 100 times over. |
posted by Xena on 2004-06-27 10:47:13 | | I agree Kandie, the author needs to make maps, otherwise it is just another map-less submission |
posted by Eric Wijnen on 2005-12-22 07:14:43 | | Straight forward invasion of undead. Able to put it into *any* kind of scenario. If you don't like it, don't use it. |
posted by Friend of Blasko on 2012-07-24 14:35:21 | | Bill Blasko is a son of a bitch. You know he goes about 7'8", 375 pounds? I once saw him scissor-kick Elminster. |
|
